Free · Printable

Free sermon evaluation form

A printable sermon evaluation form built on the 11 criteria The Sermon Coach uses, each with the question it asks and room for your notes. Use it on your own manuscript, or hand it to someone you trust to listen on Sunday. Free, and no account needed.

Or save it as a PDF from the print dialog.

Sermon evaluation form

Sermon titleTextPreacherDate

Text & Theology

Textual fidelity & exegesis

Does the sermon say what the text actually says?

Christ-centered / redemptive arc

Does it land in the gospel, or stop at good advice?

Gospel clarity

Would a non-Christian in the room know what the good news is?

Structure & Craft

Fallen Condition Focus

Does the sermon name the human pain, sin, or suffering the text speaks to?

Structure

Is there one main thing, and will anyone remember it by midweek?

Hard things handled

Does it preach the hard parts, or skip past them?

Application & Audience

Application to present audience

Does this reach the real people in the room, or stay a lecture about the text?

Emotional arc and dynamics

Does the sermon shape a clear emotional arc?

Pastoral specificity

Does it aim at specific kinds of people and real situations?

Ecclesial & Spiritual

Ecclesial faithfulness

Does this build up the church as the people of God under the Word?

Expository exultation

Has the preacher been moved to worship by what he is preaching?

The one thing to work on next

From The Sermon Coach · sermoncoach.com/sermon-evaluation-form

The criteria

Where these questions come from.

Each of the eleven criteria traces to a named preaching source. See How It's Scored →

The Sermon Coach is an independent tool. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Bryan Chapell, Tim Keller, John Piper, Haddon Robinson, the Simeon Trust, 9Marks, or any author, ministry, or organization whose published work informs its rubric. All names and works are referenced for identification and attribution only. None of these individuals or organizations, nor any author or teacher associated with them, has endorsed or is affiliated with The Sermon Coach.

FAQ

Straight answers.

Is the sermon evaluation form free?

Yes. Print it or save it as a PDF from this page. No account, no email address.

Where do the criteria come from?

They are the eleven criteria The Sermon Coach uses, under the names the evaluation uses. Each one traces to a named preaching source. How It's Scored lists the sources.

Is there a free trial?

Your first evaluation is free when you create an account. No card, no commitment. Submit a sermon, read the full evaluation, and decide from there. If it isn't useful, you've lost the time it took to paste in a manuscript.

How is this different from pasting my sermon into ChatGPT?

A general chatbot answers whatever you ask it, in whatever way you happen to ask. Ask twice and you get two different frameworks. It also tends to encourage you.

The Sermon Coach applies the same eleven criteria to every sermon, and each one traces to a published source. Every note is anchored to a line from your manuscript. Every evaluation goes into your library, so over months you can see what keeps holding and what keeps slipping. And it won't write your sermon, even if you ask.

Want the full read?

Get the same criteria applied to your sermon in minutes.

Upload your sermon free

No card. Your first evaluation is free.

All free tools