Textual fidelity & exegesis
Does the sermon say what the text actually says?
Christ-centered / redemptive arc
Does it land in the gospel, or stop at good advice?
Gospel clarity
Would a non-Christian in the room know what the good news is?
Fallen Condition Focus
Does the sermon name the human pain, sin, or suffering the text speaks to?
Structure
Is there one main thing, and will anyone remember it by midweek?
Hard things handled
Does it preach the hard parts, or skip past them?
Application to present audience
Does this reach the real people in the room, or stay a lecture about the text?
Emotional arc and dynamics
Does the sermon shape a clear emotional arc?
Pastoral specificity
Does it aim at specific kinds of people and real situations?
Ecclesial faithfulness
Does this build up the church as the people of God under the Word?
Expository exultation
Has the preacher been moved to worship by what he is preaching?
The one thing to work on next
From The Sermon Coach · sermoncoach.com/sermon-evaluation-form